I have verified now that "E ho'olohe i ka pepeiao" is wrong. Adding the "i" makes it wrong. I will test it next time to see if "E ho'olohe pono" is wrong or if "E ho'olohe pono ka pepeiao" is also wrong. But I still feel like it should have the "i".
"E ho'olohe pono i ka pepeiao" is wrong. Adding the "i" makes it wrong. This one will be hard because it feels like the "i" should be there. Or it could be wrong cause I added the "pono" which I thought was the "well" part of the sentence.