"Cos'è, un pesce d'aprile?"
Translation:What is it, an April Fool's joke?
113 CommentsThis discussion is locked.
Some other fishy sayings:
"To be at a loss" in the sense of not knowing what to do is "non sapere che pesci pigliare" which is like saying you don't know what fish to get hold of.
"A fish out of water" is "un pesce fuor d'acqua"
"A boring person" is "un pesce lesso" (Hope I'm not being that :)
Another one: "il pesce puzza dalla testa" - "the fish stinks from the head". The fish starts to stink from the head is way to say that an organization's problems alway begin from the top (who gives orders). Organization or firm or everything of that type.
Another one! To say you're "right as rain", as in very healthy, or you're very healthy again after being sick, you can say "sano come un pesce". It means you're lively and well, like a fish: always moving about when in water (or out of water!)
Lol, what's up with all the fish talk? Why is fish used to describe a person who is boring?
Have you ever eaten boiled anything? It's very plain and bland and dull.
I assume it's like our "Casper milktoast" sort of bland and pale. Just like someone is like a "wet noodle"...meh, no oomph to their personality.
he's a mid20th century comic strip character who is weak in every way. have not seen or heard of for decades
the better question is: why is it used to describe a person who is boring AND a person who is lively...
1735
> "A boring person" is "un pesce lesso"
Sort of like “a cold fish” in English? And a fish out of water is a perfectly acceptable idiom in English, too.
"A fish out of water" refers to someone out of their element. He arrived at the bar hoping to connect with a luscious babe, but he was a like a fish out of water.(unable to fit in, in this enviornment)
Nice expression, and the history behind it (read below). For beginners though, DL should stay clear of these expressions - either expand the idioms section or offer the solution as a hint... I have encountered a couple of expressions without hints which you can't possibly know what they mean and word for word translation won't do.
I fully agree with staying clear of the idioms for beginners. This is really frustrating!
No way - idioms are where you start to learn how Italians tick as opposed to just translating everything literally. I am amazed at how many idioms are the same in English and Italian. That means that Italians and English often think the same way / have the same sense of humour.
- 1551
I agree that idiomatic expressions are important when learning a language. But, the DL system encourages learning the pieces and building up and breaking down the language. That process doesn't work with idiomatic expressions. We can't really apply what we know because it doesn't make sense--which is what makes it an idiomatic expression.
- 167
I sort of agree. Not because I don't think springing idioms at us isn't a good idea - it is, it's an essential part of the language we've set out to learn. But it's confusing because Duolingo also has a very strong penchant for being annoyingly literal. I answered in the sense of April fool's joke, but felt it was a crapshoot, there being a 50/50 chance it was about a fish in April
I was confused, but don't mind the odd idiom dropped in as a way to learn. And the ensuing conversation is hilarious.
- 555
I disagree. I'm enjoying the idioms I come across, even though I have no idea what they mean, or how to translate them. Sure, I had to listen to this about 6 or 7 times, before typing what I heard, which I thought would be wrong, because it made no sense. But at the bottom, in 'meaning' it told me what it meant. Then I came here to discussions to learn more.
I'm not here to get every answer right, I'm here to learn. And when something is really unusual, I remember it even better. I don't want to be handed a whole bunch of idioms at once - I'll never remember them. But when one is thrown in every so often, it's fun, and I'll remember it.
Me too. Idioms never can be translated to their real meaning. Same in every language
Like DL says, you are learning even when you make mistakes. It is a natural way of learning languages... even idiomatic expressions.
M8 it directly translates to aprils fish. Not april fools. Thats what is being discussed: how its interesting that other languages call it aprils fish
the trouble with these vernacular phrases is the duolingo's software does not really support multiple answers
it does up to 2 from what i've seen. I guess it's at the programmer's/linguist's whim how many answers to add.
It's an expression because in April you stick a fish to people's back and wait for them to notice ! Nowadays we use papers fishes
I'd assumed so after seeing the solution, but seeing the sentence without knowing any backstory might be a little confusing.
How are we expected to know this idiom? Sometimes duolingo is so frustrating!
- 1255
You're not expected to get it the first time. The hope is that you get it every time after that. It's important to remember that you're probably not here to collect hearts, but to learn Italian. In their system, sometimes you lose a heart through no fault of your own, but you do end up learning.
- 1635
Ok, that's annoying. When you hover over the term, it says April's fool, but marked me wrong saying it should be April fool's.
when i came across this sentence, I did not know what it meant because they never taught me any of this material.
I can never remember this, has anyone found a way to remember this easily?
Well in French and Italian speaking countries, there is a tradition is to stick paper fishes behind people's back without them knowing as a prank on April Fool's day. That's why it is called "pesce d'aprile", literally "April Fish".
See, and here I had images of Italian clowns running around whacking people on the head with a floppy fish - which at least gives me an entertaining image to remember this with.
Well, this one is a gem! Must be an common idiom in Italian. A fish of April is an April Fool joke? I'll remember that one.
No wonder it made no sense to me. Its like "I am broke" having something to do with green. (I dont get that one either)
And certainly not a catchy phrase that I am going to throw into the conversation when I am sitting in a restaurant in Tuscany to show off my Italian linguistic skills!
Do Italians really use this term? "pesce d`aprile" in Spanish "dia de los inocentes" no reference to any fish in Spanish :)
- 1221
I finished this lesson months ago and have reviewed it many times and this is the first time I encounter this phrase. It's also not the first time some word or phrase only comes up when I'm reviewing a finished lesson. Is it supposed to work like that? Shouldn't we learn all of the vocabulary of a lesson before it gets golden and we start reviewing it?
The translation into English put the pronoun "it" directly before the direct object. A pronoun may replace a direct object but not accompany it.
In portuguese they have "piada de primeiro de Abril" ...that means: April 1st, joke.
- 429
What is it .... It stands for the noun already mentioned in the aentence a few words after. Odd formulation. Joke? Where is that .in the sentence??
Yes, "it" is something mentioned "off-camera". Presumably someone said something absurd or played some kind of prank. The other comments on this page explain the rest of it.
- 510
i find idioms /expressions very helpful in understanding the culture of which language we are trying to learn. Once we start seeing things their way then the language becomes easier to learn and make sense of .. so thanks everyone for sharing :)))
- 682
This is tricky, I'd only heard of April Fools day having anything to do with fish because I was in France once on that day and was taught about poisson d'avril by the local children.
I don't like these. The answer should be direct translation with maybe the meaning of it in brackets or something
And to be told I “have a typo” and it should be “Whats it, an April fool” when there is no apostrophe? Well really.....!
For me, under the "è" in cos'è, it shows that it can be "(you) are." Could this translate to "What are you, a fish of April?" That would make more sense to me seeing as that a person can be the fool or "fish." Or perhaps it is referring to the prank itself, such as the fish on someone's back?
In Italian the formal form is you is to use the 'she' tense. So "Lei è un pesce" is the formal of "you are a fish".
Does the "d'" derive from "di" or "da"? ... and why would that be? thx in advance :)
This gets more confusing!! What does a fish have to do with April Fool's!!!
Back when the Gregorian calendar replaced the Julian calendar, the start of the new year was also changed from the end of March to the start of January. People who were reluctant or otherwise slow to accept this change were mocked with fish. Why fish? Possibly because of how the old (fool's) new year coincided with Lent.
http://libguides.ctstatelibrary.org/hg/colonialresearch/calendar
https://frenchmoments.eu/april-fools-day-traditions-in-france-le-1er-avril/
seems to be a wrong hover hint, isn't it? "April's fool" - as you type it, it won't be accepted. So it's only "April fool" or "April fool's" right?
hm, obviously even "April fool's" isn't accepted, though the dictionary says it is correct.
I read this as "What is a fish of April?" like someone asking about the meaning of this phrase. (I know that Pesce d'aprile means April fool's joke like poisson d'avril in french) Now that I've seen the answer is "What is IT" I want to know how would I ask "What is ----" without the pronoun?
- 164
Does this saying refer to the joke or April fool's prank or the person who has been pranked, the April Fool,
- 172
Why is April Fool's not accepted? Even the help from Duolingo displays joke in brackets, thus optional? Or am I missing something? To be honest: I am not a native English speaker.
The 's at the end of April Fool's is the possessive. You can't just have a possessive adjective without the noun. It's an April Fool's what? It's an April Fool's joke or prank.
Without the possessive -- April Fool -- Fool is the noun and April is the adjective.
I've read the comments. I'm still confused. What does a fish have to do with April Fool's?
Would have never guessed what the phrase meant. It's similar to how we have sayings that don't translate to other languages and vice versa. (Ex. "In bocca al luppo" is a way to say "good luck" in Italian but literally translates to in the mouth of the wolf.)
It's also called the "April fish" in French.
https://www.history.com/topics/holidays/april-fools-day
How is this translated into an April fools joke... All I see is a fish of april...it makes no sense to me
- 1221
It's an idiom, an expression that can't be translated literally word by word, but only as a whole expression.
"What is an April Fool's joke?" or "What is it, an April Fool's joke?" awe man cmon...
Man I love failing a legendary level quiz because DuoLingo never told me Pesce suddenly means joke instead of Fish! Money well spent!
If anyone can work all the way through the 132+ replies (!) it should be pointed out this translation immediately confirms the speaker is not a native. It is very subtle but “What is an April Fool’s joke?” would be correct.