yeh but it's a common, accepted way to say that, just like, if someone sees an open seat in a crowded place, but doesn't want to 'steal' the seat from someone who is only temporarily away, the person might ask, 'is anyone sitting here?' even though, obviously, no, presently the seat is vacant.
or, if someone just told you a little lie as a joke, you might reply, 'are you kidding me?' even though, to be technically accurate, you mean 'did you kid me just a moment ago when you said that?' because, you know, to be accurate, the person is not still in the process of kidding you while listening to your followup question.
Does it amuse anyone else that we're being taught a sentence we'll literally never need to say? And if we do say it, everyone will know we're lying?
--I like it and I'm not complaining. I just really do smile every time I hit this one while I'm practicing verbs. It's right up there with being asked to say "I am a seal" in the animals section. At least with that one, there's a chance I'm a selkie. This is Irish, after all.
Okay, back to work...
Why do you know how to say "I'm asleep" in English, if it's something that you'll literally never need to say?
The obvious reason is that it simply fits into the pattern that you use to say "He's asleep", "I was asleep", "you'll be asleep", etc. If you understand the structure of Táim i mo chodladh, you should be able to figure out how to say "He's asleep", "I was asleep", "you'll be asleep" in Irish too.
Remember, Duolingo isn't supposed to be a phrasebook.
Táim i mo luí = I am lying down, i.e. resting, so it is related.
am luí = bedtime
No. The verb is codail and it is regular. Codladh is a noun and also the verbal noun of codail.
Amhrán álainn is ea é. Chuala mé cúpla bliain ó shin é agus mé ag freastail ar imeacht san Ambasaid na hÉireann i Londain. Bhí amhránaí sean-nós ann, agus chan sí cúpla amhrán, an ceann sin san áireamh. Chan sí "dúistear", más buan mo chuimhne, ach chuala mé "dúisigh" chomh maith, in áit eile.
Well if you really were asleep then you would not be capable of uttering such a sentence! I suppose it might be used if you were trying to get to sleep and someone else wanted to talk to you or otherwise engage your attention.
Not quite. i do is "in your", i mo is "in my".
But while Irish sentences like táim i mo chodladh or tá tú i do chónaí or tá sé ina shuí use these possessive constructions, the English translations don't - you just say "I am asleep"/"I am sleeping", "you are living", "he is sitting".
It's a year late for me to comment in this, but it is indeed correct, but your transcription is not. You were probably confusing the 'h' in the English 'hall' with the 'h' in the English 'human', which would be the closest equivalent sound to 'ch' in Irish. These are both very different sounds, but if you're used to perceiving them as the same, it's hard to hear the difference. 'ch' in Irish represents two sounds in Irish: the broad sound is like the 'ch' in German, and the slender sound is like the 'h' in 'human'. The former is what known as a velar fricative, and the latter is a palatal fricative. If you pronounce 'human' slowly and carefully, you'll notice that it's pronounced with your tongue in a similar position to a 'k', but slightly further forward, against the soft palate and is higher pitched. The 'ch' in this case is pronounced in the same place as a 'k', but with friction. Contrast this with the 'h' in 'hall', where the friction is from your throat and not cause by your tongue.
Thankfully, this is one of the easier sounds to pick up: 'h' is breathy, while 'ch' has more raspiness to it.
The link helps, your response to their question of pronounciation was extremely unhelpful. You just spelled it out. That does not help anyone unfamiliar with Irish phonetics. That would be someone learning how to speak English asking how to pronounce character and telling them it's pronounced character instead of being useful and writing it out as care-ahk-tur.
I spelled it out as Táim i mo chodladh to indicate that she pronounced the sentence accurately. I have no idea where in the world ScottishDruid is from, or what his accent or dialect of English is. To me, "tam" doesn't represent the sound that I hear this speaker say, so it would clearly be a waste of time for me to present some makey-uppy transliteration of what I hear, because it's clear that ScottishDruid doesn't use the same conventions for representing sounds that I do. Without some knowledge of how ScottishDruid interprets vowel sounds and consonants, there is no way to present an accurate transliteration just for him (and if I tried, it would be inaccurate for other people, with a different accent and different vowel sounds in their English).
English is an extremely unphonetic language - at the extreme you have "ghoti" pronounced "fish" (or "fish" pronounced "ghoti", if you prefer). If you're going to spend more than an hour or two studying Irish, then spending a little bit of time familiarizing yourself with Irish phonology will be a good investment of your time. Making a habit of transliterating from Irish sounds to English letters isn't neutral - it will actually impede your ability to "hear" what is being said. It's the kind of bad habit that you often encounter in people who have been "studying Irish for years" without making much progress. Irish orthography is a more accurate way to represent the spoken word in Irish (even given the variation in accents and dialects) than any ad-hoc attempt to transliterate (as your rather bizarre transliteration of "character" demonstrates - does the first syllable really sound like "care" to you?)
I want to politely agree to disagree but are you kidding me? We are barely past the first checkpoint in this Irish course. We have been using the English phonography for our entire lives and you expect that people in the beginning of an Irish course are immediately gonna be able to move past their hard-wired language programming and just understand the vastly different sounds letters can make in the Irish language? Where exactly are people supposed to learn how to pronounce words in Irish if not by right here?
They did not ask the question as an expert, they asked the question so they could get a better grasp on Irish pronunciation because frankly the rules are very different from English and while they may have logic behind them, I remind you that we are still beginners and we have not grasped all of the nuances yet, especially when there seems to be a difference between how certain letters are 'supposed to' sound in Irish and how things actually sound and maybe to someone with an Irish accent it might be more fluid but not everyone here is from Ireland. Anyways, if they did have an inherent understanding of the sounds of the language, they would not have asked the question. You remind me a lot of a calculus teacher I once had, they taught everything from the perspective of an expert who already knew the rules instead of bothering to ensure it was being taught effectively at a level we were prepared for. Most of the class flunked. People need an opportunity to learn at their own level, assuming people should just understand is not helpful at all and in fact can be very counterproductive and add confusion. For example, when first starting I had a very difficult time figuring out how Dia Duit was supposed to be pronounced based just on hearing it. What helped me learn was when someone typed it out as Jee-uh gWitch. I immediately knew how to pronounce it and it gave me perspective on how several letters were supposed to be pronounced, perspective I never would have gotten if it wasn't spelled out in English phonetics
Yes, it would actually be pronounced 'care' where I live. It may not be the way that it is pronounced in every English dialect, but it is most definitely how it is pronounced where I live which makes it valid. Their pronunciation of it may vary but at the very least it would get them close. What you typed would not help anyone who was at a level where they would need to ask about the pronunciation. Again, we are still in the beginners area so cut it out. They wanted to know how to process the word using sounds they were already familiar with for the exact purpose of learning Irish phonetics.
I totally get that the word was pronounced perfectly. To put the pronunciation soelling as the word spelling makes perfect sense for Irish. Irish has definite rules of pronunciation. If one learns the Irish alphabet, one can correctly pronounce every Irish word, since everything makes sense, unlike English, where, fir example, y-e-s is pronounced one way, but e-y-e-s is totally different. There are a plethora of Irish pronunciation guides to choose from on YouTube. Try looking up Jerry Kelly Irish Pronunciation for Beginners. He is the one I was recommended a few years ago. There are many more to choose from. You're welcome.