1. Forum
  2. >
  3. Topic: Dutch
  4. >
  5. "Mijn moeder gaat haar huis b…

"Mijn moeder gaat haar huis binnen."

Translation:My mother goes into her house.

September 6, 2014



Is the verb binnengaan?


Dat is nu een groede vraag: Bestaat het woord "dankjulliewel"?


I think so, ik weet niet.


Yep, but we usually say "dank je" or "dank u"


By the way, is it obvious in this sentence that the house belongs to the mother or could the owner of the house also be some other 'she'? Is there any other way than context to tell the difference? In my native language Finnish there would be different forms for these meanings.


Without context this most likely means the mother's house, however it also could mean another persons house.


Yes, it is clear that she is the owner of the house, because the sentence specifies 'haar huis'. If we just said 'Mijn moeder gaat het huis binnen', whose house it is would be unspecified.


Thank you but actually that's not quite what I meant. Obviously the owner is specified in this sentence but does 'haar' necessarily have to refer to the subject of the clause (the mother) or could it possibly refer to some other female character relevant to the context? For example if a grandmother was mentioned in an earlier sentence could it also be her house that we're talking about?

I understand the sentence and it's most likely interpretation here. I'm just speculating because I'm interested in the structures of different languages that make different specifications and leave different things to depend on the context. :)


It may confuse more but I try to open up how it's done in Finnish:

Äitini menee taloonsa. = My mother goes into her house. (her own house)

Äitini menee hänen taloonsa. = My mother goes into her house. (someone else's house)

So if we want to specify that it's the mother's own house, we only use the possessive suffix -nsa and add it to the noun talo 'house'.

But if the house belongs to some other person we still have to use the possessive suffix -nsa to mark third person but also add the possessive pronoun 'hänen'.

So in both situations it's "her house" but in the first she = mother, in the second she = someone else known in the context. (And actually, the someone else may also be a man because there's only one personal pronoun for third person with no gender specified – that's an ambiguity our language can stand. :) )


Shouldn't the "My mother goes to her house" be correct too?


No, this sentence says she goes into the house.


Shouldn't that be my house too


Not if you're not living at home anymore


But I'm only 18!


Is "My mother goes in her house" not correct, also?


why not using binnenkant instead of binner? I understand that 'binnenkant' means to enter to something specific like a room or a house.


No, binnenkant is the inside/interior of something.


Anyone who knows why not use as "My mum is going to her house"?


Because BINNEN means INSIDE. So she is actually not only getting to her house, but going inside.


'My mom goes in her house' is not valid?

Learn Dutch in just 5 minutes a day. For free.