1. Forum
  2. >
  3. Topic: Irish
  4. >
  5. "Is maith leis na cailíní lea…

"Is maith leis na cailíní leabhair faoi ainmhithe."

Translation:The girls like books about animals.

September 9, 2014


Sorted by top post


Why is it "leis" rather than "leo"? I would have expected 'the girls' to use third person plural.

September 30, 2014


Bumping this because I'm still not sure why it's "leis" rather than "leo".


leo = with them
You don't want to say "with them the girls"; you just want to say "with the girls." Usually, "with" is "le," but in front of "an" and "na," it becomes "leis," so it's "leis na cailíní."
Unfortunately for us learners, there is another "leis," the prepositional pronoun which means "with him," and that's probably what you're thinking of. You can read all about "le" here: http://www.nualeargais.ie/gnag/gram.htm


Thank you - that really helped me. I was a bit baffled... !


Go ndéana sé maith duit. Feel free to ask me questions. If I don't know, I'll tell you so.


Go raibh maith agat!


'Le' before the article becomes 'leis'. 'leis an'/'leis na'.


What about the part that means "about animals"? Does a similar thing happen? I might have expected it to be "fúthú ainmithe" because of the plural.


The 'prepositional pronouns' (fúm, fút, fúthu, etc.) are used when the object of the preposition is a pronoun (faoi + mé = fúm, faoi + siad = fúthu, etc.). Before other nouns the ordinary preposition is used, so faoi ainmithe.

In the case of some prepositions, the 3rd personal singular masculine form of the prepositional pronoun (+him/) is the same as the simple preposition: as, de, faoi.

Leis is the form of le used before the article, leis an/leis na, AND the prepositional pronoun meaning 'with him' (le + sé).


For what its worth, to add to the confusion add the recollection that cailíní is a masculine noun rather than feminine one.


So can some help with link for the difference in pronunciation between leabhar and leabhair. Based on what i've learned thus far is that thw only difference is the the r making the word mean book is round, while the r make the word mean books in a tap/flap. Is that it? Or is there a suttle change in the vowel sou d as well?


Why isn't it just "is maith na cailíní" rather than "Is maith leis na cailíní"?


Because that's not how to say 'like' in Irish. You have to include the 'le': Is maith liom X. An maith leat X? Ní maith le Síofra X. (I like X. Do you like X? Síofra doesn't like X.)

In front of 'an' and 'na,' 'le' becomes 'leis.'


Got it. Thanks Cait48. You have some good answers here.


Is maith liom gramadach!


Does DL accept leabhra as a plural of leabhar?

Learn Irish in just 5 minutes a day. For free.