1. Forum
  2. >
  3. Topic: German
  4. >
  5. how many cases can be present…


how many cases can be present in one sentence?

In one sentence can there be nominative, accusative and dative in the same sentence? Is that usually how it is? I don't know if this makes any sense but thank you :P

September 14, 2012



You can have ALL cases in one sentence :)

Wegen des schlechten Wetters (genitive) gibt der Mann (nominative) dem Jungen (dative) einen Regenschirm (accusative) - Because of the bad weather, the man gives the boy an umbrella.

A complete sentence must at least have a subject in the nominative case and a predicate. That's the minimum, e.g. Der Mann (nominative) liest.- The man reads. In very colloquial speech, the subject can sometimes be left out, but that's not standard German.

Then you can add a direct object, usually in the accusative case, e.g. Der Mann (nominative) liest ein Buch (accusative) - The man reads a book.

With some verbs, you can add an indirect object in the dative case: Der Mann (nominative) gibt dem Jungen (dative) ein Buch (accusative) . - The man gives the boy a book/The man gives a book to the boy. When you have two objects, the direct (accusative) object is normally a thing (here: a book) and the indirect (dative) object is normally a person (here: to the boy).

Also, you can add any number of adverbials whose case depends on the preposition used in them: im Haus (dative: in the house), trotz des Regens (genitive: despite the rain), ohne den Regenschirm (accusative: without the umbrella).

Or you can add a genitive by talking about possessions: Sarahs (genitive) Buch; das Buch des Vaters (genitive) - Sarah's book, the father's book.


Right. Just be glad German isn't Russian, which as 6 cases, or Latin, which has 7. :)

Learn German in just 5 minutes a day. For free.