1. Forum
  2. >
  3. Topic: Italian
  4. >
  5. "Mi è piaciuta di meno."

"Mi è piaciuta di meno."

Translation:I have liked it less.

June 13, 2013



This sentence completely confused me. I understood "piaciuta" refered to liking something/someone but the rest was beyond me. Any help?


the mi is to show that she is less pleasing to me. The e is the auxiliary verb. The di meno refers to the amount of liking


What about "it"? I thought "piaciuta" only referred to her?


I suppose it can be translated into English as it because common nouns in English have no grammatical gender whereas in Italian they do. For example, the sentence may refer to la camicia which is female in Italian, but in English a shirt is it.


But where is the pronoun lo or la to show "it" is? :O


With piacere subject and object change places, so, although I is the subject in English, mi is the object in Italian, and that makes lei/ella/essa (=she/it) the subject. And the subject doesn't have to be included in the sentence, because it is indicated by the verb, in this case è, which makes it 3rd person singular.

EDIT: And one more thing. Lo/la are directs object pronouns, but if we wanted to use a pronoun it would be a female subject pronoun and that's why I wrote lei/ella (for women) or essa (for animals and objects).


Thanks. It makes perfect sense when you spell it out like that. Why wasn't I able to work that out myself? :|


If it is female, can you say, she is a shirt, but in italian of course.


I don't think so. You would use ''essa'' instead of lei.


Thats right, an object which has no life, to have a gender.


"I liked it less" is also accepted as a correct answer, and is more likely to be used in English.


Yes, and this sentence could be useful in certain situations, like wine-tasting, for instance: "Comparing the two, what did you think of the pinot noir?" "I liked it less."


my question is more where one would use "I have liked it less" in English!?


Or I have liked it (this lesson) less than many others.


Probably never -- it's a clunky translation. "I liked it less" is an equally correct translation, and far more idiomatic English.

I can come up with a context for "I have liked it less" -- something like "I'm never sure whether I like spinach: at some times in my life I have liked it more, and sometimes I have liked it less" -- but it's a bit of a stretch. And even then, I suspect that the imperfect ("mi piaceva di meno") would be a more appropriate translation in that context.


You could use it in a sentence like "I have liked it less recently because it smells bad." Maybe? I think some sentences seem strange or uncommon because they aren't used in the context of a conversation.


Sure, but we should be translating sentences rather than sentence fragments, and as a sentence "I have liked it less" is nonsense.


Do you like work he asked? I have liked it less she replied.


Even this won't work, because in Italian you use the present for any action that continues into the present (like it smelling bad in your example), so you'd say something like "Recentemente mi piace di meno".


Maybe, I would have liked it less if the weather had been poor, or I would have liked it less without such good company. Sounds a bit unnatural but do able


In UK English I think it's "I couldn't care less" Which I think confusingly means the same as the US English "I could care less".


It is also I couldn't care less in US English. People just say it wrong.


I put 'it pleased me less' and got it wrong. Is there some reason why this is not a reasonable translation? For example, one compliment pleased me less than another did...?

  • 1071

I also got "It pleased me less" wrong - shouldn't this be OK too?!


I agree. I tried "I've been pleased with less" (which I can imagine being said and is literally accurate, I believe), but ...


what about "It pleased me less"?


I always wonder why people insist on using please (=to make someone happy or satisfied) when appeal (=to be liked by someone; if someone or something appeals to you, they seem attractive and interesting) seems to me like a much closer option.


Interesting... I will try it. Do you know if DL tend to accept forms of 'appeal' as a translation for forms of 'piacere' generally?


No, unfortunately I have no idea. But, whatever word you use to understand the grammar structure (I use my native language), I think it's still best to convert it to like because it's probably the best translation in terms of word usage and the most natural way to say it in English. It might be more difficult at the beginnig, but will become more natural once you get used to it ;)


Still not accepted 8/5/18.


why is the only correct answer piaciutA?


Does the "è" refer to the "it"? So if I wanted to say "I liked the women" could I say "mi sono piaciute le donne". ?


The voice for this one is terrible.


I used "I liked her less" and got it right


I'm really confused with this one. Which is the word that shows 'it'? I put (even though I knew it sounded wrong) 'I liked less' because I couldn't see a he, she or it there. Anyone help please?


The "it" is implicit in "è piaciuta" (it pleased).


This is such an awkward sentance!


No frip, it's really pretty dumb...


Could i say "Mi piace di meno." Would it change the meaning?


Yes. The sentence won't be in the past tense anymore.


I put I was less pleased and it was rejected


Is this not the UK English expression "I couldn't care less"? Which I think confusingly means the same as the US English "I could care less". Comments?

Playing safe I tried "I liked it less" which was OK.


"I could care less " in the US is actually incorrect, a common misconception, the expression if actually " i couldn't care less "


I translated this as "I did like it less" and I am unsure if I should complain about this or not. Does anyone have ideas on this?


Why does it suggest only 'it' and not accept 'she'? Surely that's an error?


"I liked her less" is accepted.


Could this also be: I am less pleased.


How would one say 'I like him/her the least'?


Either as above, mi e' piuciuto di meno, or di minimo, depending on how mean you want to be. Remember to change the ending a to o in the verb.


May I use AVERE to translate this sentence or must I use ESSERE?


you must use essere because the verb is intransitive.


DL also suggests "I have liked it less" as a correct translation, but isn't that "Ho piaciuto di meno"? I see that it means the same, but I often wish DL would be more consistent and focus on the issue at hand in each lesson, unless it's an idiomatic phrase, in which case it should be noted.


You cannot use ho and piaciuto together---piacere is intransitive and always uses forms of essere (not avere) as the auxillary verb. in other tenses.


"I was less pleased" was rejected. Can anyone tell me why?


that is a weird sentence


To me it is less pleasing - too old fashioned?


Why was "To me it was less pleasing" not accepted? I can see myself saying that before "I have liked it less".


Does this mean that the speaker likes it less than something else or, now, likes something more than before?


It pleased me less was not accepted


Why are we still translating piace as like? It means please, which works in the opposite direction. I wrote "it pleased me less" which is a way better translation, and it was marked wrong. This is a failure of the entire common system of understanding between Italian and english


I answered "It is less pleasing to me" - why is that wrong?


That construction would require an imperfetto like “mi piaceva di meno.” The use of piaciuto indicates that the verb needs to be in past perfect tense.

Learn Italian in just 5 minutes a day. For free.