1. Forum
2. >
3. Topic: German
4. >
5. "Die Zahlen in der Schweiz si…

# "DieZahleninderSchweizsindanders."

## Translation:The numbers are different in Switzerland.

June 20, 2013

Could this also be a reference to statistics? Could this be a response to a statement such as, "The average salary in Germany is x." ?

Yes, that would make sense.

[deactivated user]

Yes, correct. As the English use the word figure(s) for statistical data, the Germans use "die Zahlen" as statistical figures/data, hence it would make sense. Without context, this one is odd. But to get it right, a statement that the figures from Switzerland are different to others, the German would have said: "Die Schweizer Zahlen sind anders als..." In German it is often followed by a comparison. -different to. Whatever the context might be, it sounds odd. Only solution I have: Someone makes a statement about some Swiss statistical data, and another person questions that these are the correct figures, but he/she also can't recall the real ones, hence different.

I think this is a reference to the French numbering system. In France you say "quatre vingts" for 80, which literally translates into 4 20, but in other parts of the french speaking world you apparently can say "huitante", which more literally translates to 80. For a native english speaker, learning the numbers in French was very difficult for this reason and although probably frowned upon, I just went with the non-France way because I found it easier.

http://de.pons.eu/dict/search/results/?q=achtzig&l=defr&in=&lf=de

And if you've ever heard a Swiss person count, it's different from standard German :)

[deactivated user]

Oh yes, I have friends in Montreux :-) . it's so funny to hear them count for instance "drüü, füüf, sibäh, nüün" and to keep a straight face.

[deactivated user]

As we don't know the context its not easy to guess, but it sounds plausible from your point of view.

Can someone please explain to me the Time-Manner-Place rule? It appears to not be abiding by the rules here.

You only have one description here: "in der Schweiz", so you don't really need the rule. time - manner - place just helps you to sort them if you have more than one, like

"Die Zahlen sind heute (time) leider (manner) dort (place) anders."

Oh, thank you, and sorry, I took the adjective as the manner. That was a mistake.

can these words stand in for "anders"

1. unterschiedlich
2. verschieden

why "the payments in Switzerland are different " is not accepted?

Because 'payments' is 'Zahlungen' (singular: die Zahlung). 'Die Zahl' is a number/numeral/digit.

Poor pronunciation of Zahlen..sounded like 'sein' even on slow playback.

Why can't I say "The numbers in Switzerland are different?"

You can. If you come across this problem again, report it and take a screenshot so that a moderator can see exactly what happened.

why payments instead numbers is not accepted?