I wrote "is my dog with me" and it was wrong...can someone explain that to me?
If somebody does explain it, I'd like to know too. If it was my wallet or something I might ask if I have it, but my dog? He's either with me or not.
for 'is my dog with me' there would have to be a form of 'le' (with) in the sentence
I'm all confused. Every time I get a sentence it has the same words but never seems to translate the same. I put "Where is my dog?" Because all it said An bhfuil translates into was "are". I can't start a question with "are"....I think I will look in some books I have for a better explanation. I don't remember questions being this hard in Irish.
keep in mind that the word order in irrish and english ist entirely different. no, we don't start sentences with 'are' in english, but they may in irish. you have to push words around a bit for the sentence to make sense
"Are you sitting here?" - An bhfuil tú i do shuí anseo?
"Is he sitting there?" - An bhfuil sé ina shuí ansin?
"Am I sitting here?" - An bhfuil mé i mo shuí anseo?
A sentence starting with "are" or "is" or "am" in English is a question. A sentence starting with an bhfuil in Irish is a question.
In this case, the English sentence uses the verb "have", which requires the use of the verb bí in Irish, so a question like "do you have", requires the use of an bhfuil, even though the English question isn't an "am/are/is?" question.
Tá madra agam - "I have a dog"
*An bhfuil madra agam?" - "Do I have a dog?"