"In September I sing a lot."

Translation:I september sjunger jag mycket.

November 27, 2014

This discussion is locked.


What is the rule that places jag after sjunger instead of in front of sjunger?


It's called V2 – verb second. In any Swedish main clause that is not a question, the verb goes in second place. So if you start a sentence with a time adverbial – like i september – the verb must go right after that.
I wrote more about word order here: https://www.duolingo.com/comment/8970470


Thank you. I went to read your writing about word order. I do not know the word "ska," or I have forgotten it. For some of the examples, my lack of vocabulary makes the explanations opaque. Thank you for your efforts. I will come back to this when I get more advanced so that I can take advantage of your work.


It's taught pretty late in the course, in the future skill. I should probably have used examples with just the present instead, thanks for your input!


I got the V2 rule right here! Woo!


Why not 'på september'?


Months take i and days of the week take . På måndag but i september. As a mnemonic, you can think of it like this: months are a bit longer, so "in" fits them better. Days of the week are shorter, so they're more like points in time.


But i eftermiddagen... and på ögonblick!

(Though I wonder if it's like the difference between "in the afternoon" and "at night".)


For eftermiddag we have på eftermiddagen, i eftermiddag and i eftermiddags, with different meanings, see more here: https://www.duolingo.com/comment/6069004 I don't think I've heard på ögonblick, that would have to be på ett ögonblick, på ögonblicket, but there are other prepositions that are also possible with ögonblick.


I think of "på" as translating to the English "on" and "i" translating to the English "in", so as you'd say "In September" and "On Monday" in English, you'd say "I september" and "På måndag" in Swedish

[deactivated user]

    I september jag sjunger mycket. Why it marked me wrong?


    Remember the V2 rule, in which the verb must come in the 2nd grammatical "place" in the sentence (not necessarily the 2nd word, mind you). That 2nd grammatical "place" comes after "I september" in this case, so the correct answer here would be "I september sjunger jag mycket" instead of a word-for-word English translation of "I september jag sjunger mycket"


    What is the difference between "massor" (det regnar massor) and "mycket" (jag sjunger mycket)? >_> Thank you in advance.


    massor is more colloquial.


    It was correct, so I assume it's fine, but is there any difference between the answer: "I september sjunger jag mycket" and what I wrote: "Jag sjunger mycket i september"? Thanks x


    It's a question of focus, about what it is that you're trying to communicate. If you're speaking about what you tend to do in September, it's best to start out with I september, otherwise start with the subject. We're a little bit more likely to front time adverbials in Swedish than you are in English, so that you're a tad more likely to hear I september sjunger jag mycket in Swedish than the corresponding word order in English. but the difference isn't huge. Jag sjunger mycket i september is a more neutral word order in Swedish too.


    Every time i think ive grasped V2 duolingo goes and throws me a curveball


    "In September singing I much."

    My brain hurts


    Varför ordföljd ändrar här? Varför "I september jag sjunger mycket" är inte riktig?


    The verb needs to be in the second place. The first place is the adverbial "in september", so the verb has got to go right after that.


    What if this was a question - "Do I sing a lot in September?" Then what would the word order be?


    Sjunger jag mycket i september? In questions, the verb goes before the subject.


    What about "In September, do I sing a lot?"


    The word order would idiomatically still be what Arnauti wrote above. But I suppose you could say "I september, sjunger jag mycket?" with a comma.


    Could you change the word order for emphasis in the question, like in a declarative statement? I.e. "Sjunger i september jag mycket?", Or something like that? Or does that just not apply to questions?

    [deactivated user]

      I'm confused, teach us the rules!


      So according to the V2 rule, i september is the first word? Does that work the same with på måndag and other times we say "in ____"


      V2 word order is not literally one word and then the verb is the second word. The first part of the sentence is, i september. Neither of those words standing alone functions as a part of the sentence. Together they identify the point in time.


      Could you say jag sjunger mycket under September?

      Learn Swedish in just 5 minutes a day. For free.