"It is a good book."

Translation:Det är en bra bok.

March 2, 2015

This discussion is locked.


"den" does not work here? Duolingo does not accept it and I don't understand why. Any help or explanation on this would be great! Thanks.


Varför inte "det är en god bok"? Vad är skillnaden här mellan "bra" och "god"?


I’ve written about it here.


Hm. "god bok" seems like it could fit usage #3 in your list, or would that only mean that the (physical) book is well-constructed, like its pages don't easily tear out?


Yes, you could say god bok in some contexts, but it’s most common to say bra. If you use god you stress much more that it’s a personal favourite that you really enjoy reading. Whereas bra bok is more objectively ’good book’.

When people talk about god bok it’s often the whole experience of reading it, and you often hear it in contexts such as ’a cup of coffee and a good book’, ’lie in the sun reading a good book’, ’to enjoy a good book’ etc., whereas if you’d just walk up to someone and say ’that’s a good book’, you would use bra.

This is my experience as a native speaker by the way, the connotations might vary for another speaker.


I basically agree with this, I just want to add that my picture is that god is a word that has lost ground, I feel it is used less widely today than in old books, and in combination with bok is one of the places where it survives from the onslaught of bra :)


I agree, it still ’survives’ in the sense ’of good quality’ with plenty of words, but it can almost always be replaced by ’bra’ when you talk about the quality of something, which I also write in the post above: ’god/bra kvalitet’, ’god/bra simmare’, ’god/bra idé’, ’gott/bra minne’. Bra is probably more common in all of these phrases.


Tack, ni båda. Jag tror jag förstår.


why det and not den?


I wrote 'bra bok' also :)


Den (el. denna) är en bra bok borde vara acceptabelt.


Yes, I tried "den" too, and do not understand why duo did not accept it.


It's weird that I'm translating this sentence more into Esperanto than in Swedish...

Learn Swedish in just 5 minutes a day. For free.