"The wallets are yours."

Translation: As carteiras são tuas.

[vinzaprama]

why cant we use "as tuas"
please explain

[Paulenrique]

That would be correct if you added a word to follow "carteiras" (Estas carteiras são (as) tuas)

[fitzgerald1337]

I don't understand. Why is "As carteiras são as tuas" incorrect?

[djeidot]

If you say "As carteiras são tuas" it means "The wallets are yours".
If you say "As carteiras são as tuas" it means "The wallets are your wallets".

The difference is not significant, but it is roughly the difference between "it's my wallet" and "it's mine". Saying "the wallets are your wallets" feels redundant so you will almost always prefer the first sentence. "As carteiras são as tuas" is not normally used in Portuguese for the same reason, it's redundant.

[stephenpeckhover]

I used "...são sua." and was marked wrong. I thought that one person could have more than one wallet, as if he were a pickpocket, or a magician (a very unethical one ;-) )

[Paulenrique]

I think it was marked wrong because it should be "são suaS".

However, if you typed right and here it was just a typo, it should've been accepted.

[vinzaprama]

obrigado

[pfeil]

It would translate practically to The wallets are the ones that belong to you.

[Valoos75]

why not "vossas" ?

[Paulenrique]

It's no longer used in modern Portuguese, but suas (or "de vocês")

[djeidot]

"vossas" (meaning "from you all") would be correct in European Portuguese.

[pedro.feio]

"Tuas" means that the wallets are are from you, a single individual. "Vossas" means they are from you, a group of people. "Suas" can also be used, but that can mean that you are being very formal (if in european Portuguese).

[Anonymous951215]

Why was "As carteiras são suas" marked wrong? Duolingo does a poor job at explaining the differences as it always does with its vocab. and intuition based approach. :/

[mgaristova]

E quanto à "de você"?

[Paulenrique]

We don't use "de você", only "de vocês" (for you - plural)... and I don't know why,...

[jsknight]

Good thing this doesnt claim to be European Portuguese.

[Lauren.M.Q]

True, there's no reason Portuguese options couldn't be added in after feedback though, it's useful to have more than just the Brazilian Portuguese options.

[hutchbags1]

I agree. I'd like to know when to use tua as opposed to sua and when to use tu instead of você whenever I'm attempting to speak some (European) Portuguese in Portugal.

[djeidot]

The idea that "tu" and derivates like "tuas" doesn't exist in Brazilian Portuguese is just a misconception.

[naddaf.amir89]

Is it? Not what I got from my Portuguese tutor who happens to be Brazilian, and my Portuguese friends (as in from Portugal).

[djeidot]

Brazil is very big, and just because some Brazilians don't say "tu" it doesn't mean that no one says it. People from the south of Brazil use "tu" regularly, according to several comments posted by Brazilians here on Duolingo.

(and I'm pretty sure all your Portuguese friends are from Portugal ;) )

[naddaf.amir89]

Hahah. Thanks for the clarification :)

[ronaldo623]

why is "as cateiras sao suas" not accepted

[pfeil]

As carteiras são suas should be accepted.

[reshma.v]

Can i use suas?

[djeidot]

Yes, you can.

[barbaratorrance]

why do you say " sao tuas" but you say "de voces"

[TobyBartels]

It would be "são de vocês".

[LeeRogers3]

Can you say: são seus?

[Paulenrique]

You can also say "são suas".

[John235596]

Why can't you say sao voces?
I left out the accents but I know where they gol

[Paulenrique]

são vocês = are you

[princeadex]

Why can't I use "sao minhas"

[Paulenrique]

Tha is "... are mine".

[redcamarocruiser]

Can we say As carteiras são as tuas?

[MarkDeVernon]

I don't know what I was thinking, but I gave "As carteiras são as vossas" as an answer, and was marked wrong. However, I see that it might have been correct in Portugal. Is that so?