- Forum >
- Topic: Turkish >
- "Ben kitap okurum."
37 Comments
It's incorrect English. General activities with no specific object usually put the direct object in the plural. (I paint walls, I seduce men, I cook bagels, I collect doilies, etc.)
1786
Ok, but for many people there English is not their first language. I think there should be more tolerance for errors in English.
that's not possible, in general not a good idea but especially because some of these sentences are shared with the reverse course; for people who are trying to learn English.
- 1786
For me more hindering is the frustration, when you work with a really hard lesson and you loose points because you have missed "the" or added "the" in the wrong place.
I know that it's hard for English natives to believe, but there are some people in the world that use other languages which don't have articles and for them fully understanding the difference between "the" and "a/an" is next to impossible.
Well, I had the same problem in the late stages of my Portuguese course (German native speaker here). Especially in cases when a grammatical concept does not really exist in English or German or both.
Sometimes I understood a portuguese sentence well, but how would I say that in really correct English without mixing up things like "if I had" with "if I were having" and so on.
Just think of it as a possibility to improve your English.
Evet. You can see this explanation here for more information: https://www.duolingo.com/skill/tr/Accusative
I have a Turkish language book that begins with the verb form "-yor" ("okuyorum" instead of "okurum"). It will probably come up later, but can someone briefly explain the difference? Is it something like the difference between the present continuous and the simple present in English?
-yorum is the "Present Continuous Simple Tense" (singular, first person) -rum is the "Simple (Aorist) Tense" (singular, first person)
this might clear things up:
http://bit.ly/1GS3drx (link goes to: http://www.verbix.com/webverbix/go.php?D1=31[ampersand]T1=okumak which gets cut up here)
Valvocka, did you read the TIPS for accusative case? You find the answer here: https://www.duolingo.com/skill/tr/Accusative/tips-and-notes. Thanks.
The accusative marks a specific direct object (i.e. "the book"), but this sentence is a general statement about reading "books".
MeynaAyman, "the book"= a specific, definite book as in "iread the book i bought yesterday". "A book" is unspecific, indefinite book= any book.
So unless it has the ending which means "the" it could either mean a book or books (plural)? How do you know which way to translate it?
I think when one word doesn't become accusative is because it's in plural. E.g.: "Ben kitapı okurum" is "I read the book."; "Ben kitap okurum" is "I read books". (Brazilian Portuguese native speaker here)
hello Gabriel, i know a little more now. The accusative case is used when the noun, direct definite object, singular and plural : "the book or the books". "Ben kitabi okurum", "i read the book" and "ben kitaplari okurum": "i read the books". You have the singular suffix "i" (pointless i) or the plural suffix: "kitap-lar (plural suffix)-i (pointless i) (acusative case suffix. In case of indéfinite object, no singular or plural suffix: "kitap"= "a book or books". Is-it more clear?
Hello Gabriel!
I'm reading french and english grammar. It seems to me that "a book-the book-books are every four accusative cases. I read what? I read books-the book-a book?
It will be nominative case if: I read her book (she has written).
I 'll sucess in understanding .................
Hello Shrutisable! Kitap means "a book" or "books", because indefinite direct objects, singular or plural. No suffix, always the singular form. Read what i wrote to Gabriel above.
Ben kitap okurum İ read book değil mi? Books kitaplar oluyor. Ben kitaplar okurum olur i read books 'un çevirisi. Biri nerede yanlış yaptığımı açıklarsa ona çok müteşekkir olurum. :( :/
MonaRafiee, in the Turkish sentence here we have "kitap", indefinite direct object of the verb "okurum". Therefore you cannot translate "kitap okurum" by "i red the book" but "i read books or a book". Did you read accusative TIPS? You have clear explanation in it.
