- Forum >
- Topic: Esperanto >
- "Bonan tagon, knaboj!"
34 Comments
764
Only now, I'm making a connection between knabo and knaap, an uncommon Dutch word for a young boy!
And in English, a "knave". (Which used to mean a boy, but has since evolved to refer to a servant, a pauper, or an untrustworthy person.)
The word "knabo" actually comes from the German word "Knabe", which is nowadays not really used anymore but it was still standard at the time of the creation of Esperanto.
sort of: to indicate that it is made out of people from both sexes (if the stem is non-gender-neutral), you use ge- stem -oj
so children would be geknaboj
Not really.
Infano can mean infant only in the same way that "child" can mean infant.
Like in the notes "dankon" has an 'n' because its for "Mi donas al vi dankon." What is "bonan tagon" short for? "vi havas bonan tagon"? (or "havas" in future tense.. which I haven't learned yet)
When i put the mouse over " bonan tagon" it shows good day, but i type good morning and send it, it is incorrect, showing "good afternoon" as the correct translation
In this case, Esperanto follows the Germanic tradition of having a separate morning greeting (good morning, guten morgen, god morgen) and using "good day" in the afternoon. That's different from Romance languages, which use "good day" (bom dia, buenos días, bonjour, bonjourno) as their morning greeting.
This is how my teacher put it:
05:00 - 12:00 - Bonan matenon
12:00 - 19:00 - Bonan tagon
19:00 - dark - Bonan vesperon
dark - 05:00 - Bonan nokton
I can't imagine (based on more than 2 decades speaking Esperanto) saying "bonan nokton" as a greeting no matter what the hour. Possibly if someone was leaving a gathering and going back to their room to sleep, I might say "bonan nokton", but otherwise it would be "bonan vesperon" or "saluton."
I'm pretty sure that in German, you never say Gute Nacht, unless someone is in their pajamas and walking up to their room. (Slight hyperbole, but only slight.)
Telling someone "good night" in English is not a greeting but rather a good bye. What would you say to someone in Esperanto just before this person goes to bed?
Because good morning is incorrect. Good morning is bonan matenon. Good day is synonymous with good afternoon.
Becaude it’s the same concept and the Esperanto ‘tago’ comes form the German word ‘Tag’.
Think of it as "the accusative of greeting."
- Saluton - hello
- Bonan tagon - good day
- sanon - god bless you (literally "health") for sneezes.
Or think of it as "I wish you a _", "I give you a _"
it's funny, in French slang '' nabo'' means kids, childrens! I just realize
- 41
The "k" in "knaboj" sounds very sharp to me. It almost gives the sentence a sinister tone.
