1. Forum
  2. >
  3. Topic: Ukrainian
  4. >
  5. "Whose hat is this?"

"Whose hat is this?"

Translation:Чия це шапка?

June 2, 2015



Why is it not "Чия ця шапка?"


I am from Ukraine, and I think "чия це шапка" is correct too.


"ця" in constructions of this type is a standalone subject, not a modifier of "hat"


These sentences are different grammatically.

"Чия це шапка?" = Whose hat is this? -> the subject is "this", "this" can be interchanged with "it" ("Whose hat is it?"), "this" is a pronoun that plays a noun role. An answer to this question: "This is my hat".

"Чия ця шапка?" = Whose is this hat? -> the subject is "this hat", "this" cannot be replaced by "it" ("Whose is it hat?"), "this" is an attribute of "hat", a pronoun that plays an adjective role. An answer to this question: "This hat is mine".


Am I missing something about S-V-O order here? Why is it not чия шапка це and only чия це шапка is accepted?

Learn Ukrainian in just 5 minutes a day. For free.