1. Forum
  2. >
  3. Topic: Esperanto
  4. >
  5. "Kion tiu komitato faras?"

"Kion tiu komitato faras?"

Translation:What does that committee do?

July 2, 2015



Omg... why so many double letters?



are you talking about "committee" i never realised how bad i am at spelling in my "native tongue" until i began using duo lingo...and especially now that im studyng esperanto i get frusterated at how un intuitive english's spelling is...i know its got a rich history which explains why this happened...a history which im a fan of..but cant we have a reformation...or something..either way..i love esperanto's phonetic qualities


Every language has it's weird things ;)


English is a lot weirder than most. I'd go as far as to say that even french has a more regular written language than English. English has ~12 vowels + complex diphthongs + long and short versions of all that, which do not correspond to the spelling at all. "Team" should have a diphthong but is usually pronounced /tiːm/, whilst "near" /nɪəɹ/... WTF


English is very strange XD


No, - OK, well yes - but English is an organic version of what Esperanto was designed to be - it has never been a language spoken only by one country and forced on anyone by force (which is true of some European languages).

English is the product of different cultures (e.g Celt, Angle-Saxon and Viking) coming together and gradually working out a common language denominator, dropping complexities and overlapping grammatical methods and accounting for a wide range of different pronunciations etc. from all of these different tongues - and that is even before you even start to introduce the influences of Latin and French.

The result is that yes, it can be complex, but also, and for the same reasons, one of the most expressive languages that you can come across.


Not to be a "Debbie Downer" but English absolutely has been forced on people, that is the history of English colonialism and so many people today speak it due to that.


Russian. Much weirder than English. I am a native Russian speaker and here, on Duolingo courses (EO and EN) I realized, how weird Russian is.

I admire all who are learning Russian, you are a kind of heroes!


Kamelo estas ĉevalo ke estis desegnita da komitato. :)


In English "what are they doing" and "what do they do" have different meanings, but Esperanto likes to group them as "kion ili faras". How would you differentiate that nuance in Esperanto?

[deactivated user]

    I agree with you about the English. I think that, "What does that committee do?" means, "What is the role of that committee?" which in Esperanto would be, "Kio estas la rolo de tiu komitato?"


    The problem is it's twice the words. ... "Kiel ili rolas?"

    [deactivated user]

      But wouldn't that have yet another meaning? "Kiel" = "how" or "in what way", so "Kiel ili rolas?" means something like, "How do they play a role?" If you want shortness, I suppose "Kia estas tiu komitato?" would mean roughly the same as my "Kio estas la rolo de tiu komitato?"


      "Kiel ili rolas" or "Kiel ili agas" sounds like effective shorthand for asking how something typically behaves, to me. Maybe awkward in direct translation, but such goes for many phrases. "Kia" only asks what kind or type it is, not how it behaves, so is more indirect.

      Learn Esperanto in just 5 minutes a day. For free.