1. Forum
  2. >
  3. Topic: Irish
  4. >
  5. "Tá seaicéad orm."

" seaicéad orm."

Translation:I have a jacket on.

July 10, 2015



When speaking English, I try not to end a sentence with a preposition. Why isn't it correct to translate this phrase as "I have on a jacket. "?


Here, "on" is not a preposition per se, but part of the phrasal verb "to have on".


What about "to wear" instead of "to have on"? Of course it's less literal...

[deactivated user]

    It rejects "I am wearing a jacket" even though to have a jacket on implies one is wearing it.


    But wearing is a different word

    [deactivated user]

      Different languages express the same idea in different ways. Here Irish expresses it as 'There is a jacket on me' whereas English would express it as 'I am wearing a jacket', 'I have a jacket on me', 'I have a jacket on', 'I have on a jacket'.

      In Ó Dónaill's Irish-English dictionary under meaning II(e) for the preposition ar there is the following:

      (e) (Of anything covering or enclosing, attached to or supported by body or thing) Tá clár, clúdach, air, it has a lid, a cover. Tá úlla ar na crainn, the trees are bearing apples. Tá mála mine air, he is carrying a bag of meal. Bhí culaith ghorm orm, I was wearing a blue suit. Dá mbeadh trucail ar an asal, if the donkey were drawing a cart.


      Not now. It dinged me and gave me this as the right answer, 'I'm wearing a jacket.'


      The answer "I have on a jacket" was rejected. Odd.


      To everyone saying "I have on a jacket" is incorrect in English, it's not. It's correct in some dialects, including mine. If Duolingo accepts "y'all" (it does), then it should also accept this construction.


      Agreed. It should just be reported in the hope that one day the alternate translation will be added.


      I have on a jacket doesn't work....so how would one say " I have on a jacket.?


      Did I miss why, 'I am wearing a jacket' is accepted but, 'I wear a jacket.' is not? Is there a tense difference in Irish between the English present progressive and the present?


      Yes. The tenses are different in Irish, as they are in English. Caithim seaicéad = I wear a jacket (habitually, generally); Tá mé ag caitheamh seaicéid = I am wearing a jacket (today, right now). Note that seaicéad takes the genitive form seaicéid after the verbal noun ag caitheamh.


      Some are wrong when you pit on at the end, and others are right! There's no consistency!

      Learn Irish in just 5 minutes a day. For free.